Search Episodes
Listen, Share, & Support
Listen to the latest episode
Subscribe via iTunes
Subscribe via RSS
Become a fan
Follow on Twitter

Support Us:

Please consider making a donation to help make this podcast possible. Any contribution, great or small, helps tremendously!

 
Subscribe to E-Mail Updates

Related Readings
  • Answers for Aristotle: How Science and Philosophy Can Lead Us to A More Meaningful Life
    Answers for Aristotle: How Science and Philosophy Can Lead Us to A More Meaningful Life
    by Massimo Pigliucci
  • Nonsense on Stilts: How to Tell Science from Bunk
    Nonsense on Stilts: How to Tell Science from Bunk
    by Massimo Pigliucci
  • Denying Evolution: Creationism, Scientism, and the Nature of Science
    Denying Evolution: Creationism, Scientism, and the Nature of Science
    by Massimo Pigliucci
Thursday
Jun242010

RS12 - What About Thought Experiments?

Release date: July 4, 2010


Philosophers are often accused of engaging in armchair speculation, as far removed from reality as possible. The quintessential example of this practice is the thought experiment, which many scientists sneer at precisely because it doesn’t require one to get one’s hands dirty. And yet scientists have often engaged in thought experiments, some of which have marked major advances in our understanding of the world. Just consider the famous example of Galileo’s thought experiment demonstrating (rather counter intuitively) that two objects of different weight must fall at the same speed. And, perhaps more famously, Einstein's thought experiments on the nature of light.

And then, there are the other kind, like philosopher David Chalmers' famous thought experiment about zombies and the so-called "hard problem" of consciousness. Chalmers comes up with an (admittedly ingenious) little story, and we are supposed to deduce from it the momentous conclusion that there is more than matter/energy to the universe? Still, there are plenty of good thought experiments in philosophy, beginning with the so-called trolley dilemmas meant to probe our moral intuitions.

Comment on the episode teaser.

Julia's pick:  "50 Great Myths of Popular Psychology: Shattering Widespread Misconceptions about Human Behavior"

Massimo's pick: John D. Norton Goodies

References (1)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.

Reader Comments (10)

You mentioned that the only treatment that had empirical evidence for being successful was CBT for mental health disorders. I've found some research that show rates of remission for disorders (other than schizophrenia) that psychodynamic psychotherapy is at least as effective as CBT:
Driessen, et al
Leichsenring
Fonagy, et al.
Dierckx.
I am curious why you would choose not to report on these findings, or if you just hadn't come across them. I normally really enjoy your podcasts and have listened to every one. I just couldn't help but feel a little slighted when after major myths in pop psychology only one form of therapy was reported to be effective.

Thank you for hours of enjoyment on previous podcasts,
Myles

July 5, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterMyles

If the fat man in the trolley experiment is fat enough to stop a trolley, then he won't budge if you try to push him off the bridge. Therefore, you'd have to use a lever to apply more torque :-D

July 5, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterMax

Great episode, as always, but I just wanted to offer a correction. Towards the end of the episode, Massimo stated something to the effect that 'CBT is the only "talk therapy" that is empirically supported.' This is a common misconception, and one that I was surprised to hear Massimo echo.

Research data shows about equivalent efficacy for all forms of psychotherapy -- referred to as "the Dodo bird verdict" by Luborsky, Singer, and Luborsky (1975), in reference to conclusion reached by the Dodo bird in Alice in Wonderland, 'Everybody has won, and all must have prizes.'

For further reference, I suggest consulting 'The Efficacy and Effectiveness of Psychotherapy' by Lambert & Ogles (2004), 'A Meta-(re)analysis of the effects of cognitive therapy versus "other therapies" for depression.' by Wampold and Minami (2002), 'Current findings regarding the effectiveness of counseling: Implications for practice' by Lambert & Cattani-Thompson (1996), and 'Research on psychotherapy efficacy and effectiveness: Between Scylla and Charybdis?' by Nathan, Stuarat, & Dolan (2003).

July 6, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterMichael

Shouldn't the link for "Goodies" go to: http://www.pitt.edu/~jdnorton/Goodies/

July 11, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterZwirko

Really interesting discussion of thought experiments, but Galileo is a tricky example since he did do many experiments on falling bodies, particularly his inclined plane experiments. In a sense, Galileo formulated the thought experiment as a model that could be presented in Aristotelian terms. Galileo understood his opponents!

As an historical sidebar, the inclined plane experiments were also thought to be thought experiments for many years until Stillman Drake discovered Galileo's notebooks that recorded his work.

July 16, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterAndrew

I thought the thought experiment about the arrow was not that of Zeno and is known as Zeno's arrow paradox. Here it was referred to as the Lucrecia . I could easily have misheard or that I'm mistaken...
Just curious...
Btw the Zeno's paradox in a quantum context interests me also.

July 17, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterKaren

Oops, errata to my comment above:
"I thought the thought experiment about the arrow was not that of LUCRECIA...

I can type or I can think, but I can't do both at the same time.

July 17, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterKaren

With christian louboutin venetian pumps in black, you are going to usually ought to ask numerous as humanly doable. Any sensible buyer will do not need christian louboutin pump with your situation.Look at the label! The christian louboutin poseidon sequins pumps, having said that, some shoes could have the label glued on, as an alternative to christian louboutin gold and white leather rutus high top sneakers. This is ordinarily a huge sign the excellent of all those christian louboutin freddy studded lace ups white is not really actually value income you happen to be just about to dedicate to christian louboutin cow leather wedge black. This brings me towards the christian louboutin blue suede slingback. Look at the stitching! A quality Christian louboutin shoe should really have near-perfect stitching and christian louboutin toundra short boot, for not plenty of far better phrases.The shoes allow for her to personal amid the best of sexual mind-set. The sort of frame of christian louboutin red leather-slingback that speaks of the significant number of panache! These christian louboutin platform slingback lilac showcase the mysterious outcomes and a variety of individuals who are christian louboutin n.prive leopard fabric slingbacks. Specifically, the louboutin sale Contente OTK Grey Suede christian louboutin n.prive fabric slingbacks leopard is definitely a beautiful nappa leather boot this can be the correct and and so the christian louboutin glittered slingback burlywood in trend. It is the highest motto of various trend women!christian louboutin colorful chatons slingback is everywhere, and then for us babes cheaply, this can be unquestionably excellent. Even so, normally there are a few louboutin christian louboutin brown slingback that men and women must avoid including the plague! Why? We have now a substantial distinction amongst high top quality christian louboutin black silk slingback and poor quality Christian sneakers. When you may be saving lots of cash on obtaining louboutin footwear in lieu of genuine christian louboutin slingback in red, you could possibly nevertheless be ripped off during the function the expertise with the Christian Louboutin Egoutina Spike-Toe Suede Boots Cream is just not there. I will share each of the suggestions you require to just keep in mind to are becoming the very best deal when acquiring Christian Louboutin shoes.First and Christian Louboutin Contente Over-The-Knee Suede Boots Grey, depend on your intuition! Should your gut is informing you that men and women sneakers are overpriced for your personal quality, or Christian Louboutin Contente Over-The-Knee Leather Boots Black which is just will not feel proper walk away or question various issues.
Christian Louboutin manufacturer significant Christian Louboutin Contente Over-The-Knee Leather Boots Black are appreciated by Stars specifically Hollywood stars and so are the most top-level shoe brand. Talking bluntly, Also i really like the red sole large heel shoes, unquestionably no rationale, completely for it is Christian Louboutin Bourge Patent Tall Boots Black, if the selling prices usually are not much too expensive, There’s without doubt that I will take pleasure in it more and will purchase quite a few Christian Louboutin Big Lips Thigh 120mm Boots Black women superior heel sandals. But when it’s not at all so pricey, it can be probable not Christian Louboutin Big Lips Booty 120 Leopard-print.Currently, Christian manufacturer significant heel shoes can be obtained at higher tariff of 800USD as well as a lot more, but there’s even now quite a few consumers to obtain. From slightly information and facts we could discover additional, which include Christian Louboutin Big Lips Booty 120 Ankle Boots Black spend in a very pair of Christian louboutin footwear for his daughter who only one as well as a fifty percent yr previous, the quantity is 3000 USD. You are able to picture how the charming these Christian Louboutin Bibi Botta 140mm Suede Boots Black have.”I are able to see the entire world, quickly placed on Christian Louboutin Alti Botte 140mm Leather Boots Camel”. With that said, you are going to usually ought to ask numerous interrogation as humanly doable. Any sensible buyer will do not need an issue answering them with your situation.Look at the Christian Louboutin Zip-Back Over-the-Knee Boot! The fact remains, having said that, some shoes could have the label glued on, as an alternative to stitching.
ganjames

January 9, 2012 | Unregistered Commenterred bottom shoes

Just to mention that both link in the picks section link to the John D. Norton Website. Now I'm going to actually have to copy text into a search bar. *huffs loudly*

December 11, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterMatt

Sorry, just wanted to point out a broken link.

"50 Great Myths of Popular Psychology: Shattering Widespread Misconceptions about Human Behavior" currently leads to the John D. Norton Goodies instead.

Okay, technically that's not a "broken" link, more of a misdirected link. Regardless, it is does not link correctly.

P.S. I really appreciate the links to the picks for each episode. You are feeding my brain even further.

September 17, 2014 | Unregistered CommenterJay

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.